Skip to content

November 7, 2017

Logitech Craft review

by John_A

On the surface, Logitech’s new Craft keyboard looks like a run-of-the-mill, low-profile wireless keyboard with a copycat Microsoft Surface Dial bolted on (Logitech calls it the Crown). In practice, it’s much more than that, offering a surprising amount of control for such a seemingly simple addition to a standard keyboard.

As this keyboard is primarily targeting creatives who rely on applications like Adobe Photoshop, we are approaching our Logitech Craft review from that perspective. The keyboard also offers benefits for non-creative uses, but for these non-creatives, the $200 price tag might be harder to swallow.

The keys to success

The design of the Craft is simple but effective. Beyond the creative applications of the Crown, Logitech has taken steps to make this a great keyboard for typing. Typing enthusiasts (yes, they exist) aren’t likely to give up their beloved IBM Model F, but after banging out a couple thousand words with the Craft (including this article), we can confirm that it does feel quite nice. The keyboard also has a nice weight to it with very sticky rubber feet, so it won’t slide on your desk, even if you fire off a hotly worded email in all caps

Bill Roberson/Digital Trends

Bill Roberson/Digital Trends

Bill Roberson/Digital Trends

Bill Roberson/Digital Trends

Logitech redesigned the keycaps with a circular indent to help guide your fingers into the right position. The company says this helps with accuracy, but we’re not sure if it makes a huge difference. At any rate, it does feel quite comfortable, and the keys offer a good amount of resistance and spring back quickly. They are also backlit, and the light will turn on automatically when your hands approach the keyboard and off again when you remove them. Given that the Craft is wireless, this probably helps save a little battery life (which Logitech claims is good for one week).

The Craft connects over Bluetooth Low Energy or via Logitech’s Unifying receiver. There are no batteries to replace; instead, simply plug the keyboard in via USB Type C (a cable is included) and you can continue to work while it charges.

A crowning achievement

The Craft’s most notable feature is the Crown, a free-rotating input dial that resides on the upper-left corner of the keyboard. In addition to turning it, it can be pressed like a button and is touch sensitive. Purely from a design perspective, it makes the keyboard look a little off balance as it leaves a lot of empty space along the top bar. Other than the Crown, there’s just the battery status light on the right.

The Craft offers a surprising amount of control for such a simple addition to a standard keyboard.

Logitech told Digital Trends it went through numerous other ideas, including a touch interface similar to the Touch Bar on the MacBook Pro, but after listening to input from creatives, it ended up with the single dial on the left side. The idea is to keep your right hand on the mouse and with your left hand on the keyboard where it can reach the Crown and common keyboard shortcuts, all at the same time and while your eyes remain forward on the monitor.

This scaled-back approach is a bit different from bespoke creative control interfaces like Palette and Loupedeck, which offer multiple dials, nobs, and buttons. Instead, Logitech relies on a custom driver to make the Crown more versatile than it looks.

It begins with context sensitivity, and the Craft ships with specific commands for several applications from Adobe and Microsoft. In Adobe Photoshop, for example, simply tap the side of the Crown to move through the a list of commands displayed at the bottom of the screen, which will change depending on which tool is selected. Simply rotate the dial to adjust the selected parameter, which might be opacity, blend mode, or brush size. Remove your hand from the Crown, and the onscreen display fades away. In a web browser, you can use the Crown to cycle through your open tabs.

Bill Roberson/Digital Trends

In addition to preinstalled application profiles, you can program the keyboard manually for other applications. Currently, this is somewhat limited: You can set custom keystrokes for turning the dial or pressing it, but you can’t set multiple different parameters to cycle through by tapping it.

At $200, it isn’t exactly cheap, but it does provide value for the right users.

In Adobe Lightroom Classic, which is not yet officially supported, we set the dial to adjust the currently selected slider, but we still had to cycle through sliders using the standard keyboard shortcuts (or clicking on them with the mouse). Even so, using the Crown felt like a much more natural way to make adjustments — although it was a tad slow for making big changes, as it took the slider an oddly long time to catch up to the dial. We expect this could be solved by official Lightroom support from Logitech in the future (should they decide to offer it). The company also said it will be offering an SDK that will allow developers to add native support for the Crown.

One small detail we really like is how the Crown provides two different styles of movement, based on context. In the sort of infinitely-variable parameters found in Photoshop, like adjusting brush size, it turns freely and smoothly. In other situations, such as switching tabs or turning up the volume, a physical ratchet mechanism engages that provides satisfying click points and good tactile feedback. This makes a huge difference in actual use and feels much better than the vibration-based haptic feedback of the Surface Dial.

Is it worth it?

Logitech’s streamlined and simple approach means the Craft gives added control and flexibility without complicating the experience. At $200, it isn’t exactly cheap, but it does provide value for the right users — namely, photographers and video editors. It’s a great keyboard all around — there isn’t anything that’s directly comparable — but it is in creative applications where it really shines.

That said, it does offer some benefits to non-creative tasks. Rotating the Crown to turn up volume or adjust brightness, or even using it just to scroll down a long list of emails in your inbox, is a surprisingly refreshing experience — even if it’s not altogether faster than using keyboard shortcuts. The Craft comes with profiles for Microsoft Excel, Word, and PowerPoint.

Right now, the only thing really holding it back is the lack of native support for more applications. In particular, we would really like to see profiles for Adobe Lightroom and Apple’s creative apps (Photos, iMovie, Final Cut Pro). However, even with its current limitations, the Craft has certainly grown on us. It will be hard to go back to a standard keyboard.

Editors’ Recommendations

  • 6 best products showcased at Adobe MAX 2017 conference
  • Logitech Craft with ‘creative input dial’ is crowned new flagship keyboard
  • What’s the difference between Lightroom CC and Lightroom Classic?
  • Macphun Luminar 2018 review
  • Adobe’s new Lightroom leverages the cloud for cross-platform photo editing




Advertisements
Read more from News

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Note: HTML is allowed. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to comments

%d bloggers like this: